Talk:BPG Iron Gall Ink

2023 BPG Wiki Discussion Session on IGI

A virtual discussion session about this page was held on June 8, 2023, as a post session of the 51st AIC Annual Meeting. Participants used this Google doc to record their ideas during the session: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1SeNt3VfWW2_MOd0wsz71w8szExIUoFu5rVK4YgeqfwI/edit -Msmith (talk) 18:34, 8 June 2023 (UTC)

Rename page?

Should this page be renamed as "BPG Iron-Gall Ink"?

I see that many of the sources cited on the page use the hyphen, but it seems like no-hyphen is more common throughout the page at present. Personally, I don't use the hyphen (and neither do a handful of colleagues I just briefly surveyed), so I guess I have a bias there. The Iron Gall Ink Wikipedia page and the Iron Gall Ink website both do not use the hyphen. This wiki page shows up in the wiki search results for either spelling, which is good. Since both appear to be in common usage, I don't think either one is wrong, but I would advocate for using whichever is more familiar to most people working in the US, since the wiki is a product of AIC. I'm not sure how we determine that. What are your thoughts? -Msmith (talk) 15:45, 10 October 2023 (UTC)

A similarly brief survey of the people working on this wiki page returned a preference for the unhyphenated version. CAMEO uses "iron gall ink". The Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus prefers "iron-gall ink" --Kkelly (talk) 20:05, 27 November 2023 (UTC)

New section on gelatin?

KK suggest a section entitled Gelatin (taken from CM's bibliography)